by Fabio Marques
Few heroes have been asked to share a page with as many
gods, kings, and prophets as the Man of Steel. Superman was born during the
Great Depression as a modern myth, but he was never built from scratch. Every
few years, a writer reaches back into the old stories and pulls out a familiar
face, and the result is always a little surprising. Hercules is the most
obvious choice. Moses is the one many readers feel in their bones, even if the
creators never said so. And there is a third influence that is easy to forget:
John Carter of Mars, the pulp hero from Edgar Rice Burroughs, who arrives on
another world and becomes a champion there. Superman’s own story of a stranger
from another planet owes something to that adventure tradition.
Hercules and Superman share far more than their surface
differences suggest. Both are measured by feats of superhuman strength, both
are sent into a world of ordinary people to perform impossible tasks, and both
carry a divine or near-divine heritage. Hercules is a demigod, son of Zeus and
Alcmene, with a club, a lion skin, and a long list of labors. Superman is a
Kryptonian who grew up on a Kansas farm, hides his powers behind a pair of
glasses, and files stories at a newspaper. The costumes and settings are
different, but the resemblance is deep enough that Elaine Caruth could build an
entire study around it. The Moses parallel is more subtle, and I think it
deserves a closer look. Moses was born to enslaved Hebrews at a time when
Pharaoh ordered that the Hebrew boys be thrown into the Nile. His mother hid
him in a basket of reeds on the river, and he was raised as the adopted son of
Pharaoh’s daughter in the Egyptian palace. Kal-El is sent away in a rocket as
his world dies, and he is raised as a farm boy by the Kents. Read the two
stories side by side, and the origin and upbringing are simply reversed. The
shape stays the same: a child from a persecuted people, hidden in a vessel,
raised among outsiders, and destined to protect the people he came from.
John Carter deserves more credit than he usually gets. Edgar
Rice Burroughs introduced him in 1912 in A Princess of Mars, a Civil War
veteran who wakes up on Mars, where the lighter gravity gives him a strength
and a leap he never had on Earth. He becomes the champion of a people who are
not his own. Superman’s story runs the same path in reverse: a visitor from
another world whose powers come from a new sun. Of all the influences in this
article, Burroughs is one of the few with a documented link to the creators. Jerry
Siegel and Joe Shuster admitted the influenced in the 1983 seminal interview to
Thomas Andrae in Nemo: The Classic Comics Library, issue #2, August 1983, pages
6–19. The pulp formula of a stranger from another world who becomes a champion
is part of the character from the start.
The earliest Superman and Hercules connection goes back to
1944, when Superman #28 published “Stand-In for Hercules!” The idea is
wonderfully playful. What if the famous Twelve Labors were never done by a
mortal strongman at all, but by Superman, quietly helping out and letting the
myth take the credit? I remember reading that concept as a kid and feeling like
I had discovered a secret about history. Superman was not just a hero from
another world. He was the hero behind the legends.
The direct confrontations came later. In 1960, Action Comics
#267 and #268 brought Hercules into the modern day. Lex Luthor, never one to
pass up a bad idea, dragged the Greek hero out of ancient times to take down
Superman. Hercules, it turns out, had his own opinions about Luthor, and the
two-part story became a glorious tangle of jealousy, Olympian pride, and Lois
Lane caught in the middle. It is pure Silver Age fun, and I still smile when I
think about it.
The crossovers did not stop there. In Adventure Comics #257
(1959), a Superboy story called “The First Two Supermen!” brought Hercules,
Samson, and Krypto into the young hero’s world, an early taste of the mythic
company Superman would keep. In Action Comics #308, on sale in November 1963
and cover-dated January 1964, Superman travels to a parallel world and helps a
Goliath-Hercules accomplish seemingly impossible tasks. In Action Comics #320
(1965), Clark summons evil versions of Hercules, Samson, and Atlas from another
dimension to help defend Metropolis, not knowing they are evil. Superman then
defeats them one at a time. In Action Comics #351–353 (1967), Hercules and the
gods of Olympus create Zha-Vam, a champion built to defeat Superman. Superman
travels back to the age of the gods to learn the creature’s origin, and he
finally defeats Zha-Vam through an alliance with Neptune. The most recent clash
came in Justice Society of America #13 (2008), where Hercules bloodies
Superman’s nose, only to be soundly defeated by the visiting Kingdom Come
Superman.
Hercules also has a place in the wider DC universe, and that
is where things get interesting for Wonder Woman fans. Diana is a princess of
the Amazons, who in DC’s version are tied to the Greek gods and their myths, so
the heroes of Olympus are never far from her story. Hercules belongs to that
same mythic world, a legend of strength and labor who sits uneasily between
ally and rival. DC’s mythology is one big family tree, and every branch touches
the others.
Some critics saw the mythic side of Superman early. Elaine
Caruth, a clinical research psychologist, presented a version of her paper
“Hercules and Superman: The Modern-Day Mythology of the Comic Book” at the 43rd
Annual Meeting of the American Orthopsychiatric Association in April 1966, and
it was published in 1968. She opened with a letter a boy had written to
Superman’s Pal Jimmy Olsen in 1964. The boy loved the stories in which Jimmy
travels to the past and meets heroes like Samson, Hercules, and Atlas, and he
asked what the magazine would do “when you run out of heroes?” Caruth argued
that the early comics were replicas of mythological heroes from the past. She
quoted the folklorist Quennell, who predicted that “future folklorists will
find in them the mythology of the present day.” She also described Kal-El’s
separation from his parents and his expulsion from Krypton, the kind of loss at
the heart of many old myths.
Then there is the pattern that ties these figures together.
In The Hero with a Thousand Faces, published in 1949, the mythologist Joseph
Campbell described a structure he called the monomyth, a journey he traced
across world religions and legends, including the stories of Moses and Jesus.
Campbell identified 17 stages in his formulation of the monomyth. Christopher
Vogler later developed a twelve-stage adaptation for screenwriting. The hero is
often born under unusual circumstances, is hidden or sent away, is raised far
from home, receives help from a guiding figure, faces a series of trials, and
returns to serve the people who need him. Measured against that pattern, the
figures in this article start to look like one hero wearing different masks.
Samson is born to a barren woman after an angelic visit, dedicated to God
before birth, and sent to fight the Philistines. Moses is hidden in a basket,
raised in a foreign court, and returns to lead his people out of bondage.
Hercules is the son of a god, tested by a goddess’s jealousy through his twelve
labors. John Carter is carried to Mars, where he becomes the champion of a
people who are not his own. Superman is sent from a doomed planet by desperate
scientists as a last hope, and he is raised by a kindly couple who dedicate him
to protecting the world that adopted him. Campbell never wrote about Superman,
but later writers have applied his framework to the Man of Steel. For example, it
was mapped the twelve stages onto Mark Waid and Leinil Francis Yu’s Superman:
Birthright, showing how Clark’s origin follows the hero’s journey step by step.
That pattern gains a personal dimension when we look at the
creators. Jerry Siegel and Joe Shuster were two Jewish teenagers from
Cleveland, sons of immigrants, and their documented influences were open and
varied. In a 1983 interview with Nemo magazine, Shuster called Winsor McCay’s
Little Nemo his favorite strip, and Siegel recalled that Superman’s dual
identity came from his own meek, bespectacled self. Both creators loved Tarzan,
and the adventure strips of the period shaped their sense of what a hero could
be. Critics have also read Samson, the golem of Prague, and Moses into the
hero. Those parallels are interpretations rather than statements from the
creators, and Campbell’s framework helps explain why they keep appearing.
The most moving modern use of the myth, though, is All-Star
Superman, written by Grant Morrison and drawn by Frank Quitely, which ran from
November 2005 to September 2008. The series runs twelve issues, and its
challenges work like the labors of the Hercules tradition, though the match is
thematic rather than a one-to-one copy. Superman saves the first manned mission
to the sun, brews the Super-Elixir for Lois Lane, answers the Ultra-Sphinx’s
unanswerable question, chains the Chronovore, saves Earth from Bizarro-Home,
returns from the Underverse, creates life on Qwewg, liberates Kandor and cures
cancer, defeats Solaris, conquers Death, builds an artificial heart for the
sun, and leaves the formula to make another Superman. Hercules does not appear
in the book at all, and that is exactly what makes it so clever. Superman
learns he is dying from overexposure to solar radiation, and rather than
retreating into despair, he sets out to do as much good as he can before the
end.
The strongmen Samson and Atlas share the stage, and one
moment makes the connection explicit. Samson, a time traveler who has been
feuding with Atlas over Lois, speaks to Superman as if the hero is already
gone: “Just before your death, it’s said you completed 12 super-challenges, the
stuff of legend.” He lists the deeds one by one: you created life, you escaped
from the Underverse, you overthrew the tyrant sun, and you answered the
unanswerable question. Superman’s reply is a single word, “What?”, the reaction
of a man who has been doing the work without thinking of it as legend. The
biblical strongman hands the hero the myth that Hercules is famous for, and
Superman is the last to hear it.
This is where the book becomes special. Hercules was a
figure of brute strength who had to learn humility, discipline, and the cost of
his own rage. Superman’s labors are about something else entirely: curiosity,
compassion, and the decision to keep giving even when there is nothing left to
gain. The punches and the monsters are almost the least important part. When I
reread the series, I am always struck by how small and human the big moments
feel.
People often ask who would win in a fight between the two.
Hercules has the myths on his side, and Superman has the sun. But the older I
get, the less that question interests me. What matters more is what each hero
would do with the time he has, and in that comparison, Superman has always had
the edge in my book.
Gods fall and myths fade, but the stories that outlive them
are the ones that keep finding new hands to carry them. Hercules carried the
weight of the heavens on his shoulders, and Superman carries the sun in his
heart. Somewhere between the labors of Hercules and the twelve challenges of
Kal-El lies the oldest promise of all: that a stranger from far away can become
the hero the world needs. So tell me, which Superman and Hercules story has
carried you furthest? I suspect some of you have a better answer than mine, and
I am always eager to hear it.
